Submissions to guix-patches keep increasing, but the rate at which they’re closed doesn’t quite keep up:
debbugs.gnu.org/rrd/guix-patch (see “All bugs ever opened”)

How do #FreeSoftware projects encourage committers to review? Any insight to share?

#Guix thread: lists.gnu.org/archive/html/gui

(HT to zimoun)

Follow

@civodul
Would be interesting to know why people are not reviewing. Anyhow, asking those who are not here is an issue :-/

Speaking for myself: I unsubcribed guix-pathes long ago, since there have been to many pathes and discussions - and in the mail-based workflow issues keep open/unread (in my inbox) even if done. Using debuts in emacs I never got familiar with.

Maybe(!) mail-based workflow is what hinders people. Welcome to the old discussion about tooling. Not even sure, tooling will help.

@kirschwipfel @civodul I think tooling is major, I think providing tools to reviewers to quickly address reviews at a glance (UI/UX!!) certainly motivates reviews. You feel discouraged when you know something could be automated and you do it lots of time everyday. When I was still contributing to the project I tried raising that argument of tooling to motivate reviews, I think everyone is kind of burnt out so it's easy to raise that point but difficult to solve

@kirschwipfel I think it’s a problem for a committer to not be on guix-patches since that leaves the reviewing burden on others.

I understand that email-based workflows is a hindrance to some, just like web-based workflows are a hindrance to others.

In terms of tooling, issues.guix.gnu.org was developed to help those who prefer a web interface. Perhaps a starting point?

Sign in to participate in the conversation
NerdCulture

All friendly creatures are welcome. Be excellent to each other, sei humanistisch, keine Nazis, keine Hassrede. Nicht nur für Nerds, aber die Domain ist irgendwie cool. ;) Keine Bots im Allgemeinen erlaubt! (nur mit vorheriger Genehmigung). Sprache ist hier hauptsächlich Deutsch, Englisch auch erlaubt. --- All friendly creatures are welcome. Be excellent to each other, live humanism, no nazis, no hate speech. Not only for nerds, but the domain is somewhat cool. ;) No bots in general! (only with prior permission). Main language is German, English is allowed.